
Dictation or typing: measure your own speed
Until now you had to believe that speaking is faster than typing. Here you measure it. You type a short text and see your words a minute, then you hear the same text spoken and watch the words arrive, and both numbers stand next to each other.
By Pavel Hegler, founder of shepetal. Updated
Measure it
I will send the revised contract before lunch tomorrow. Please check the numbers on page two and tell me if the delivery date still works for you.
Your words a minute appear when the text is complete.
Side by side
| shepetal | Apple Dictation | |
|---|---|---|
| On-device or cloud | On your Mac, and your voice stays there. | On your Mac or on Apple’s servers. Its privacy page says Keyboard Settings show whether dictation is processed on your device; otherwise, Apple’s servers process it. apple.comsupport.apple.comas of |
| Offline | Works offline.shepetal downloads speech recognition on its own after you install it, and one more file when you choose a language outside the 25 European ones. | On a Mac with Apple silicon, for supported languages, says Apple’s guide for macOS Sonoma 14. support.apple.comas of |
| In any app | Works in every app.When an app blocks paste, your words wait for you on the clipboard. | Yes. Its guide: “anywhere you can type it.” support.apple.comas of |
Every line on another app here comes from its own pages, and each one links the page and the day we checked it. shepetal is independent of these apps and of the companies that make them.
How the test counts
A word in this test is five characters, which is how typing tests count, and the spoken text is counted the same way, so the two numbers compare. The clock for your typing starts with your first key and stops when the text is complete, and pasting is switched off. The number for speaking is the one that the study below measured for people. A voice reads the same text, so that you hear it and see the words arrive.
What a study measured
In 2016 Sherry Ruan and four other researchers published a study that compared speech and the keyboard for short messages on a phone. Its result for English: “the English input rate was 2.93 times faster (153 vs. 52 WPM)”, and for Mandarin Chinese it was 2.87 times (123 vs. 43 WPM). Speech made fewer errors while people wrote (5.30% against 11.22%), and it left more of them in the finished text (1.30% against 0.79%). The study ran in a laboratory, with people who copied given messages. arxiv.orgas of
Where the keyboard wins
A reply of two words is typed before you have pressed a dictation key, and code and tables are quicker by keyboard, because there every character counts. Dictation wins where you write sentences: mails, chat messages, notes and prompts. The finished text counts too, so read what you dictated and correct it, the same as you do with what you type.
Where shepetal fits
With shepetal you press one key and talk, and your words appear where your cursor is, in every app on your Mac. It turns your voice into text on your Mac, so once it has downloaded speech recognition it works with no internet.€24 once. Yours forever.€2 a month.
Which to pick
Pick Apple Dictation if
- You write a few short messages a day and want the dictation that is part of macOS.
Pick shepetal if
- You write mails, chat messages, notes and prompts most of the day, and the test above showed you what typing them costs you.
- You want to stay in the app you are working in. You press one key and talk, and your words appear where your cursor is.
- You dictate client names, contracts and private notes, and you want them turned into text on your Mac, also when you have no internet.
Read next
- How to dictate on Mac
- shepetal or Apple Dictation
- Dictate your essay on a Mac
- Dictate in Cursor, VS Code and Terminal
- Dictation apps for Mac
Sources
30 days free
€24
once. Yours forever.
€2
a month.
30-day money-back guarantee.
Write to support@shepetal.app within 30 days of your one-time payment or your first monthly one. Pavel, who builds shepetal, sets up a short call with you where you tell him what is broken or why you do not like it, and then you get your money back. This comes on top of your legal rights, including the right of withdrawal.
If you have more questions, the FAQ and the Privacy Policy answer them.